It’s Time For Vaccine Talk Detox

Seems a pity that, on seeing the words “top 10 unfounded health scares,” the first thing I thought about was……….vaccines and autism.

Many speak of a “debate” about an alleged vaccine-autism link and that there’s a “controversy” brewing here, but it’s a false controversy. 2008 saw the publication of more studies refuting a link, and yet there’s been a call for more studies—-among the $1 billion in research initiatives noted in the Strategic Plan of the IACC is an item about the “different health outcomes in vaccinated, unvaccinated and alternatively-vaccinated groups”—so it’s not as if this particular topic is going to go away.

Sometimes, one starts to wonder, will this particular topic ever go away? How many studies will it take to convince those who believe so very much that there is a link, that there really isn’t one?

Of the 3,393 or so posts I’ve written here, hundreds and hundreds and hundreds have been on vaccines. In the course of writing those posts, and reading about vaccines, about autism, about vaccines and autism, and about what people think about vaccines and autism and about why people think there’s a connection between their child becoming autistic and vaccines, the one thing I’ve mostly been left with is a sense of need—-a sense of needing to know—-of searching for the one answer about why and how this happened—-of needing to do the right thing. In an age when every single step of child rearing, from pre-conception to pregnancy, from labor to birth, from infancy to the first birthday to toddlerhood, from preschool to elementary school to hitting the double digits (10 years old!) to (gasp) adolescence, is not only scrutinized—-is written about in books, magazines, and websites galore, parents seem more and more haunted by the need to get it right.

And when one’s child is disabled, that need seems only to get compounded, as parents (myself included) seek “the best,” or the “most appropriate,” or the “highest quality” services, teachers, therapists, and programs for their child. As much as you know—as I know—that you and I did everything we should and could have done for our child, still that worry nags and lingers, that maybe you and I could have done something different. On the one hand, I’ve gotten pretty good at ignoring stares from strangers; on the other hand, there’s always an unspoken fear that maybe I am doing something wrong; that I’m a bad parent. Why else did those “autism is just another excuse for rotten parenting of rotten kids” remarks by Michael Savage and Denis Leary earlier this year strike such a note earlier this year?

What if we really are such bad parents; what if the likes of Savage and Leary are right?

And it’s that voice-in-the-back-one one’s mind, it’s that twinge, that “maybe” that has something to do with why, scientific evidence to the contrary, the notion that vaccines are somehow linked to autism just won’t die.

So here’s a possible resolution for the new year: How can we detox ourselves from talking about the hypothetical vaccine-autism “link”?