David Kirby exonerates thimerosal
October 28, 2008 by Kristina Chew, PhD
Filed under Cause, Diagnosis, Epidemic, New Jersey, Vaccines
So thimerosal’s not the “‘smoking gun‘” linking vaccines to autism, according to David Kirby, whose 2005 book, Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Vaccines and the Autism Epidemic: A Medical Controversy argued that thimerosal—-a mercury-based preservative—-was the culprit behind what he calls the “autism epidemic.”
From an article in today’s Star-Ledger (New Jersey) about an October 23rd forum on infant and child vaccines at the Deirdre Imus Environmental Center for Pediatric Oncology at Hackensack University Medical Center:
[Kirby]…..said he believed that thimerosal, which still exists in trace amounts in some childhood vaccines, was no longer the “smoking gun.” Several national studies have found no connection, and a California study found that, even after thimerosal was removed from vaccines, diagnoses of autism continued to rise.
But, he said, the links between vaccines and conditions like autism are still strong and more research is needed. One area to look at is to determine which children might have a genetic propensity for a condition such as autism, for which vaccines may act as a trigger.
……
“New Jersey is lousy with mercury,” he said, much of it from air pollution that is spread in rain.
But he also pointed to the “universality of vaccines” as an explanation for so many children’s contracting chronic illnesses.
“Not everybody lives near cell phone towers, uses the same baby food or household products, but everyone gets vaccines,” he said. He cited the example of the immigrant Somali population in Milwaukee. Pregnant women, mothers and babies were given up to 10 vaccines “and the autism rates among Somali refugees are through the roof,” he said.
So Minneapolis (not Milwaukee) is “lousy” with Somali children who have autism (which is not, of course, a “chronic illness”)?
As everyone knows, it’s generally said that New Jersey is simply “lousy”; based on the autism education Charlie’s gotten here, with speech therapy and OT and daily PE integrated into his school day, and good lines of communication between the teacher and me thanks to email and the phone, I would beg to differ. (But I do tend to weigh education and schools heavily in my thinking.)
And as for it raining mercury here in Jersey? It has been raining all day here—-snowing even in some places—-Charlie and I got a bit wet on our way to the dentist office. He’s never been inclined to use an umbrella—-good thing we both have hooded rain jackets—-neither of us has yet to become more autistic.
So now that thimerosal’s off the suspect list for causing autism, what’ll be next?
Jeff Stimpson
Jill Cornfield