I think I’ve figured out why – as far as reality TV goes – Bravo’s Thintervention With Jackie Warner is more compelling than NBC’s The Biggest Loser. On Thintervention, contestants are eminently more relatable, because not all of them are morbidly obese (as many are on TBL). Most of Jackie Warner’s eight subjects are just overweight, and each one has relatively moderate weight-loss goals of anywhere between 25 to 60 pounds (relative to TBL contestants, that is).
Because of this, it’s much easier for most of us to understand and empathize with the weight these Southern California residents have gained over the years. You can see that several of them were once thinner, fitter people – athletes, even – but that life’s demands and obstacles (family, work, stress, depression, childhood traumas, etc.) have simply gotten in the way – resulting in an often lifelong, on-again-off-again downward spiral of weight gain and unhealthy living. You can easily envision the same thing happening to you (or at least I can), which is pretty terrifying. (Stupid empathy!) It’s like how certain people think that they could never, ever become homeless; but then they lose their job, their house, their money, and their family. And then it’s pretty easy to see how the whole thing happened. More »