How do measure greatness when it comes to being a dad? askmen.com published an article last month called 12 Traits of a Great Father, written by Julian Marcus.
List includes:

1- He’s a good disciplinarian
2- He allows his kids to make some mistakes
3- He’s open-minded
4- He teaches his children to appreciate things
5- He accepts that his kids aren’t exactly like him
6- He spends quality time with his children
7- He leads by example
8- He’s supportive & loyal
9- He challenges his kids
10- He teaches his children lessons
11- He protects his family at all costs
12- He shows unconditional love

Read full article.